Neutrogena Skin ID Review – 7 Important Pros and Cons Revealed

Misleading Neutrogena Skin ID reviews are everywhere. This is my in-depth unbiased review, and it will uncover what is and what is not of Neutrogena Skin ID. 7 Pros and Cons will help you decide if Skin ID is a desirable product or not.

Acne is the worst. For countless years, I tried plenty of products and solutions created by companies claiming to have finally found the cure. Some of the products worked better than others. Others were a waste of time and money. I don’t expect miracles, and I never did. I always hope that any new acne treatment will result will be fewer noticeable breakouts within a reasonable amount of time.

Before trying any new acne product, I read the reviews of people who have already tried it. After I found out about Neutrogena Skin ID, I checked out its reviews and this is what I found — although it is not the perfect product, it is worth a try.

How Does Neutrogena Skin ID Work?

Neutrogena begins its order process with a detailed questionnaire. Before ordering the products, you will need to answer several questions, such as age, gender, skin type, skin tone, whether or not you have sensitive skin, type of acne, products used before, and many more. Some Neutrogena Skin ID reviews contained complaints about the length of the questionnaire, but I believe that the company is doing potential buyers a favor because not everyone has the same skin type, and we all have different circumstances.

The purpose of Neutrogena’s questionnaire is to recommend a custom combination of Skin ID products in order to produce the best results. Based on your answers, Neutrogena Skin ID recommends a personalized skin care system using 3 products: an anti-acne treatment, a combination cream cleanser/mask, and a moisturizer. These products are each given a separate number that customers use to order the product.

Some Neutrogena Skin ID reviews claimed that the custom combination made it difficult to order because some were afraid they might choose the wrong product by mistake. However, I found that it was necessary to answer the Skin ID questionnaire as accurately as possible to obtain the best product recommendations. Why wouldn’t you want your personal formula designed to give you the best possible results?

Does Neutrogena Personalized Skin Care Really Work?

It is important to understand that Skin ID alone will not cure your acne. You need to make a commitment to follow the instructions on the labels and use your products regularly and as directed. In other words, follow the directions exactly in order to derive maximum benefit from your Skin ID!

According to various Neutrogena Skin ID reviews, the products seem to work well. Consumers are confident because the products are personalized to their particular needs. Some reviewers were skeptical that the personalization of the product was a ploy in order for Neutrogena to sell more products. However, many had significant confidence in the company, because they were already familiar with its popular, high-quality drug store brand.

Skin ID Vs Proactiv Solution

The company claims that its Skin ID product line is twice as effective as Proactiv Solution. Several Neutrogena Skin ID reviews back this claim, and many users of all age groups claimed that the product produced immediate effects. I had difficulty finding many negative Skin ID reviews.

Neutrogena conducted its own clinical trial with 500 volunteers and discovered positive reactions overall. According to the company’s own findings, participants in the trial showed 70% improvement in just two months. Neutrogena Skin ID was successful in the trial early on, and the company provides the following numbers:

  • Visible results for 86% of users during the first week
  • 90% visible difference by the end of the second week
  • 94% change during the third week
  • 100% difference at the end of the first month

Several Neutrogena Skin ID reviews claimed that the product was ideal for sensitive skin and that it wasn’t nearly as harsh as Proactiv. Other acne products work better (such as Exposed Skin Care), but they are also significantly more expensive.

Keep in mind that you may not need the most expensive product if your acne is mild. My acne is mild; therefore, the only difference I find between products is the length of time it takes for them to begin working and how long the products continue to work. However, moderate acne sufferers suggest that the product took much longer to work, and it wasn’t as effective as it was on mild acne sufferers.

What Are the Advantages of Using Neutrogena Skin ID?

The biggest advantage of Skin ID is that it has a 60-day money back guarantee. This serves as a great, no-risk incentive for those who are wary of either trying a new brand or switching to a new product. However, Neutrogena requests that you pay return shipping and handling charges. Not a bad deal.

If you like the product, it is extremely cost effective at $19.95 a month.

As I mentioned earlier, Neutrogena Skin ID is clinically proven to be effective and fights acne at the first sign of breakout. Skin ID also receives a rating of 2.8 out of 5 stars.

The free custom questionnaire is detailed enough to create a personalized skin care system designed with you in mind. In fact, the system will not allow you to order any products until you have completely answered the questionnaire. Neutrogena is the first company to come out with an acne product that is personalized; in fact, there are 25 possible combinations of formulas.

With All These Advantages, What Could Possibly Be Negative?

Some Netrogena Skin ID reviews offer complaints that at an initial price of $40, the product is overpriced. However, its initial cost is still less expensive than its main competitor, Proactiv. Also, I did not like that when I went to order the product, Neutrogena gave me no choice but to put me on an automatic re-ordering schedule. That type of system does not work well for me because I would most likely forget to cancel. 60 days is a long time to remember to cancel an ongoing order if you do not wish to continue.

Some Skin ID users complained that the products did not meet their expectations, especially if their skin was extra sensitive or if they suffered from moderate acne. Additionally, some product reviews indicated that Skin ID had a consistency that was thicker than preferred and that the product had a disagreeable odor. Some reported that the product’s consistency was similar to butter.

Additionally, several users complained of redness, dryness, swelling, itchiness, and greasiness.

The bottom line is that you need to decide for yourself. I can only tell you my experiences with this product as well as share some information from other Neutrogena Skin ID reviews. However, each case is different and what works for me may not work for you.

Neutrogena Skin ID Discount Codes

If you are budget conscious and looking to get rid of a few mild pimples, then Neutrogena Skin ID Products are definitely worth giving a try! Here are 4 Neutrogena Skin ID promo codes for $10 off ( IPHaBUFF, IVHJGWEJ, neutrogena10, CLEAR432 ).

7 Pros and Cons


  • Very popular product
  • Works well on mild acne
  • 60 day money back guarantee
  • No prescription is needed
  • Personalized skin care
  • Cost effective
  • Conducted a clinical trail with 500 volunteers


  • Less effective on moderate to severe acne
  • Some Reported skin irritation on sensitive skin
  • Initial price of $40
  • Acne fighting strength is too mild
  • Moisturizer might clog pores for oily skin
  • Redness and dryness if over use
  • Average customer service
Previous post 5 Ways to Add Easy Vegetable and Fruits to Your Child’s Diet
Next post Will Garlic Each Day Keep Cancer At Bay?